Herbal pills for cancer 'do more harm than good'

Published: 14 Nov 2019   

Online Desk

Cancer patients should tell their doctors if they are taking herbal products because some of the ingredients could stop their treatment working, a cancer conference has heard.

Garlic, ginger and ginkgo pills, for example, can delay the healing of skin wounds when breast cancer spreads.

Surgeon Prof Maria Joao Cardoso, said there was no evidence that herbal therapies or creams worked.

If in doubt, it was best not to take anything, she said.

"Doctors need to be more proactive about asking their patients what else they are taking when they are being treated for cancer," Prof Cardoso, head breast surgeon at the Champalimaud Cancer Centre in Lisbon, Portugal, told the BBC.

She said it was particularly important that patients always checked with their doctors first before trying complementary therapies for cancer that had spread to the skin.

This happens in one in five cases of breast cancer - and less in other cancers.

The danger is that many products can interfere with hormone therapy or chemotherapy treatments, and certain ones prolong the blood clotting process - which can lead to wounds taking longer to heal and more scarring.

She highlighted the following herbal products as examples of those which slow down clotting:

green chiretta

feverfew

garlic

ginkgo

ginseng

hawthorn

horse chestnut

turmeric

'Do no harm'

Prof Cardoso said it was not surprising that patients and their carers went searching for complementary or alternative treatments that might make a difference.

But she said people should know "they could end up doing more harm than good".


"The highest goal in medicine is important to remember: do no harm," she said.

On its website, Cancer Research UK says some complementary therapies might stop conventional treatments working as well as they should.

It also says it is important to avoid some food and drinks such as grapefruit and oranges during cancer treatment, because they can affect how well cancer drugs are broken down in the body.

The charity says: "Talk to your doctor about any complementary therapies you're thinking of using. Tell them before you start having complementary therapy, especially if you're in the middle of a course of cancer treatment."

Grete Brauten-Smith, clinical nurse specialist at charity Breast Cancer Now said: "With a lot of unproven information available online and little reliable research into these products, a discussion with a healthcare professional can ensure a patient has the accurate information they need to make an informed choice."

Speaking at the Advanced Breast Cancer Fifth International Consensus Conference, Prof Cardoso said therapies like yoga, mindfulness, reiki and acupuncture could have a positive impact on patients' quality of life.


ACC recommends blacklisting 14 contractors of health sector

ACC recommends blacklisting 14 contractors of health sector

The Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) has sent a letter to the ...

ICT probe body to scrutinize list of Razakars: Anisul

ICT probe body to scrutinize list of Razakars: Anisul

Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Anisul Huq has said ...

Freedom Fighters' final list on March 26

Freedom Fighters' final list on March 26

Liberation War Affairs Minister AKM Mozammel Haque has said a ...

India not pushing anyone into Bangladesh: FM

India not pushing anyone into Bangladesh: FM

Foreign Minister Dr AK Abdul Momen on Sunday said India ...

"Will seek president's rule In Bengal if violence continues": BJP

"Will seek president's rule In Bengal if violence continues": BJP

Accusing Bangladeshi Muslim infiltrators for being behind the ongoing protests ...

13 killed in Nepal bus accident

13 killed in Nepal bus accident

At least 13 persons were killed and dozens got injured ...

Citizenship Act is India’s own internal affairs: Quader

Citizenship Act is India’s own internal affairs: Quader

Awami League General Secretary Obaidul Quader has said that the ...

Armed forces to be made more well-trained: PM

Armed forces to be made more well-trained: PM

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has said the government has been ...